Yesterday, in my new role as shadow secretary of state for health, I asked Jeremy Hunt to explain the financial crisis growing at the heart of our NHS.

This morning the Conservative chair of the health select committee joined a growing chorus of voices and declared the Government’s NHS spending claims to be “inaccurate” and “false“. Time and time again we have been told this government is investing £10 billion more for the NHS, a claim Jeremy Hunt repeated to me this afternoon. However, as members of the health select committee made clear this morning this figure “is not only incorrect but risks giving a false impression that the NHS is awash with cash” and “does not stand up to scrutiny”.

The letter raises very serious questions about the claims that the government has been making, indeed the only way they could be discredited further is if they decided to slap them on the side of a bus and have the Foreign Secretary parade it around the country.

Sadly Jeremy Hunt refused to admit today that the government has simply not given the NHS the resources it needs. He refused to give an accurate account of the spending plans for the NHS, and, of course, he refused to admit that on his watch hospitals have been left in the worst financial crisis in a generation with unprecedented deficits of £2.45 billion.

It is becoming increasingly clear that patients and staff are paying the price for the government’s failed policies. A survey carried out by Health Service Journal recently found that as part of sustainability and transformation plans one in three local areas intend to close or downgrade A&E departments within 18 months, one in five expect to close consultant-led maternity services, and that more than half plan to close or downgrade community hospitals.

The secretary of state, of course, said he did not recognise the picture painted by the survey and did nothing to allay the fears raised by it.

I even asked Mr Hunt whether he agreed with the chief executive of the Patients Association who said earlier: “Cuts will only put even greater stress on services already buckling under the pressure of continual cuts, poor workforce planning and lack of proper long term investment.” Sadly, I don’t think he does. If only the government would admit there was a problem, they might finally get around to doing something about it.

Labour will always accept change in the NHS when it is clinically led and done in the best interest of patient care. However, it is clear that the main driver of the sustainability and transformation plans is to force through cuts and try to deliver unrealistic savings. When change is forced through to cut corners it is the patients who pay the price.

I think patients have had enough of broken promise after broken promise from this government on the NHS.

I think it’s time Jeremy Hunt and co stopped the spin and came clean with the British public about the desperate state of the NHS on their watch.

This was first published by LabourList 

Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed.


  1. rotzeichen says:

    It really is time for shadow health ministers to stop prevaricating and launch a direct assault on the Tories for deliberately underfunding the NHS in order to privatise it.

    The Neo-Liberal agenda is clear and the tactics used are historically factual, £20 billion taken out in the first four years of the coalition, then a further £20 -£8 billion in this last term of office, the £8 billion referred to Stevens request for more money over this period.

    The Tories are being allowed to get away with dismantling and privatising our NHS, these documents spell out in their own words what they intended to do and now achieved:

    Nicholas Ridley’s 1977 paper on how they would denationalise the state and how they would use the arms of government to subvert the unions.

    Margaret Thatcher’s secret 1982 cabinet papers, “the longer term options” released under the 30 year rule in 2012, detailing how they would dismantle the state and put all public services into private hands, including schools and the NHS.

    Please tell me people are going to wake up.

  2. rotzeichen says:

    Sorry forgot to add the last link: Margaret Thatcher’s 1982 cabinet papers:

  3. F.M says:

    I think it’s time Jeremy Hunt and co stopped the spin and came clean with the British public about the desperate state of the NHS on their watch.
    (Copied from above)

    The above implies to me (maybe I’m wrong) that the NHS has somehow unintentionly found itself in a decline on the Tory’s watch. It has always been the deliberate intention of the Tory’s to get rid of the NHS, thus underfund, understaff say it’s not working therefore it must be privatised.

    1. Nicholas says:

      Yes, that’s a really awful thing for an “opposition” to insinuate.

      “Praising with faint damnation” it effectively writes off the government’s agency and intent. The exact opposite of what the opposition must do.

Comments are closed.

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 828 other subscribers.

Follow us on Twitter