So, what’s it all about?
With over 200 Clinical Commissioning Groups set to take over the commissioning of services from April, it will be incredibly hard for the public and health workers to know what’s happening with regard to their services in time to do anything about it effectively. Whether or not the government’s ‘Section 75’ resolution goes through, CCGs will be under pressure to include private providers in the provision of services, and private providers will already be working hard to gain influence over CCGs. It will be extremely difficult for activists to have a clear picture of what’s going on, let alone to co-ordinate action.
However, the NHS Constitution gives statutory rights to patients and public, and places specific, statutory duties on NHS bodies. The rights include:
  • to be involved in discussions and decisions about your healthcare, and to be given information to enable you to do this. (NB: not just treatment, but wider healthcare)
  • to be involved, directly or through representatives, in the planning of healthcare services, the development and consideration of proposals for changes in the way those services are provided, and in decisions to be made affecting the operation of those services
In addition there are (non-statutory) commitments that form part of the constitution. These include a commitment “to provide you with the information you need to influence and scrutinise the planning and delivery of NHS services (pledge); and to work in partnership with you, your family, carers and representatives” and “to engage staff in decisions that affect them and the services they provide, individually, through representative organisations and through local partnership working arrangements.”
The document also places expectations on anyone working within the NHS:
  • to play their part in sustainably improving services by working in partnership with patients, the public and communities
  • to view the services they provide from the standpoint of a patient, and involve patients, their families and carers in the services you provide

Based on these rights, duties, commitments and expectations, I believe that it will be possible for the right person or group to:

  • engage with local communities and unions to be named as a ‘representative’ to allow a legally-underpinned interaction with CCGs
  • require of CCGs to provide timely information on any plans to change how services are provided, especially details of planned tenders or approaches to the AQP marketplace
  • work with local communities and unions to demand representation on the CCG and involvement in both discussions and decisions about awards of contracts to provide NHS services
  • demand that ‘best value’ is applied in its widest sense of long-term sustainability, public ownership, community impact (through lost wages and restricted services due to private companies taking a profit margin etc) and the retention of public NHS personnel and infrastructure that, if lost to a private provider, will be very hard ever to reacquire or rebuild
  • provide a central, easily-accessible source of information for individuals and community action groups to know what their CCGs are doing or planning and a partnership to help co-ordinate the above actions
  • challenge awards to non-public entities
The aim of CCGWatch, if I can get it off the ground, will be to:
  • provide a central repository of information on CCGs’ plans and tenders/FOI requests
  • build contacts with local unions, activists and residents to engage them in the decision-process
  • contact every CCG to remind them of their statutory duties and to require them to provide information on their plans, tenders and any conflicts of interest
  • publish details of plans, tenders, invited bidders and decisions
  • co-ordinate resistance to the transfer of services to private providers based on the information obtained as a legal right
The key thrust of the project is aimed at CCGs as the name suggests, but the same principles could apply to other threats to services as well.
Obviously it’s going to be a big job, so all help is appreciated!  If you can help finance this it would be helpful.Any questions or issues, please let me know, otherwise I look forward to hearing about the next steps we can take.
Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed.


  1. This sounds a great idea. Anyway I can help ?I do a Newsletter for patients in Wandsworth about what is happening in the CCG. Can send you the latest copy if you want.

    1. skwalker1964 says:

      Thank you Mike (and Martin)! Yes, funding is the key issue at the moment so if you belong to any groups you could circulate the funding page, or if you know of any organisations or individuals that sometimes help fund NHS-related stuff, it’d be great to know the details.

      I’d be very interested in your newsletter either way, though!

  2. Martin Rathfelder says:

    You could put out an appeal for money:


    We have set-up a small campaigning group caalled 38 DEGREES-NHS-LEICESTER.
    We are setting out to do all the things you have mentioned. On top of that, we are trying to establish a more meaningful relationship with our UHL Hospitals.

    1. skwalker1964 says:

      Thanks for the info. I’m happy to co-operate with other groups, although a main reason I set up CCGWatch was because I suspect the big campaigning organisations, with their wide range of issues, won’t have the focus on this particular issue. I also think there are benefits to doing something that looks at the issue nationally.

      That said, engaging with local groups will be vital!

      1. Gay Lee says:

        Have you talked to Paul Evans at the NHS Support Federation and Caroline Malloy at Keep our NHS Public? You need to coordinate with them as they are doing work/setting up data bases which almost certainly will overlap or even coincide with yours.

        1. skwalker1964 says:

          Yes, I have – met Paul on Monday in London.

Comments are closed.

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 827 other subscribers.

Follow us on Twitter