CITIZENS’ VOICES OR CONSUMERS’ CHOICES?
In Wales, we still take pride in community. Our patients, our nurses, our doctors, our hospitals; before the NHS that’s how Welsh health services grew, and how we still think of them. Because science is always advancing, we’re always learning to care more and better for people with growing expectations, so our NHS can never stay still, but neither our NHS staff nor our hospitals want or need competition to make them work harder or faster. Consumer choice won’t create more staff or hospitals, our main problems after many years of under-funding. We have no surplus, so choice between competing providers can only mean that one patient’s gain is at the expense of another.
Health care is not a commodity like clothes or holidays, for which consumer choice is appropriate. Its efficiency and effectiveness depend on co-operation between citizens and staff, flexibility and understanding that there is nearly always somebody else worse off than we are, and that staff can’t do more than their best. In return for that understanding, we expect staff truly to do their best. Though we’re rarely disappointed, we need to develop much more community participation in policy and day-to-day running of NHS Wales, with more constructive criticism from users, and less destructive criticism from news media.
How to do this, in reality not just words, depends mainly on studying local best experience, and then applying that experience everywhere. So far, less than 1% of people qualified to elect representatives to Boards of English Foundation Hospitals have used their vote; power has moved from central government not to the people, but to local bureaucrats hand in glove with corporate business. In Wales we want every level of NHS care to have local representatives elected by users in the communities they serve, but as well as this formal democracy we need to encourage beginnings already made by voluntary bodies created by people with specific problems who are high users of the NHS, giving them a voice in development of the services they use. From these beginnings, which already exist, we might develop more participative citizens with their own intimate knowledge of health problems. We need to understand how intimidated most people still are by doctors and other experts. These more specialised voluntary bodies need help from the Assembly to make them better known and meet some of their administration costs, perhaps through the UK Expert Patients Programme, which is already centrally funded.
We need citizens’ voices not consumer choices, but health care can’t be delivered in standard packages, it must reflect the very different needs of individual patients, and of course this entails choice. This is not new. We have always known that care is more effective and efficient when given by staff who know their patients well through continuing responsibility and shared local records, so they can adapt care to personal needs. The time of a mother with three young children is just as scarce and important as the time of specialists, and referral arrangements should reflect this. Patients should have real choices between terminal care at home or in hospital, which means more funding for home care and hospice support, not just for cancer, but all terminal illness. We have always defended the right of patients to choose their own GP. More flexibility is needed to provide some choice between specialists when relationships break down, particularly in psychiatry, but just as choices between GPs can be made within primary care teams, choices could be made between specialists within hospitals. Much more needs to be done to resist fragmentation and division of services which disrupt this continuity, and shopping around between doctors and hospitals rated by league tables won’t help.
We also need, and are already getting, an increasing choice between new kinds of specialist care both by doctors and nurses. A few rare or extremely difficult problems may need to be concentrated at single centres serving the whole of Wales, with a monopoly of care, because that is the only way to ensure that ultraspecialist staff get enough ultraspecialised experience, but for most problems wider choices can be developed economically within easy reach for visiting by family and friends. A wider range of specialist skills and opportunities for advanced training within each primary care team and each District Hospital, so that each has a full range of specialist staff appropriate to those levels of care, could be achieved by investment in those units working in co-operation, not as business trusts competing for patients.
Shopping around for care among competing providers is not the answer to our problems, it would make them worse. The Assembly has roughly doubled intake of medical students and nurses for university courses, but this will take about 10 years to produce new staff actually working. There is no quick solution. When eventually we get these new staff, we shall need them to work for the NHS, not for private companies recruiting staff trained by the NHS to do the easiest parts of care for profit. The NHS in Wales will remain what most Welsh people have always wanted and still want – our own doctors, nurses and hospitals, all doing their best in a public service planned to meet health needs, not profit.
- Health & Care Data Wales 2024-01-24
- Drakeford promises most radical days ahead 2023-06-12
- Opening the market – NHS Wales? 2023-03-19
- Modernising planned care & reducing waiting lists in Wales. 2022-10-01
- REBALANCING SOCIAL CARE IN WALES — Response to Welsh Government White Paper on Social Care. 2021-05-17
- Realistic hope for a Social Care system driven by Human Rights from Scotland 2021-02-19
- Social Market Stability in Wales — Consultation Response SHA-Cymru 2021-02-03
- A WELSH BENEFITS SYSTEM MAKES SENSE 2021-01-25
- EDUCATION AND COVID ADVICE == WALES 2020-11-15
- SHA Cymru statement in support of the First Minister and Welsh Government 2020-11-06
- ASSESSING THE VIABILITY OF THE SOCIAL CARE SECTOR — Response to Welsh Government Proposals 2020-10-07
- WALES — HOW SUSTAINABLE IS OUR CARE SERVICE ?? 2020-09-24
- A Scalpel or a Butcher’s Knife to our Public Services —- and to the UK? 2020-08-25
- TEST, TRACE AND PROTECT IN WALES; A PUBLIC SERVICE RESPONSE TO COVID-19 2020-07-21
- SHA Cymru Wales: Response to Welsh Labour’s Stage Two Consultation paper on health and social care. 2020-06-17
- Blanket DNACPRs are not the solution for panicked healthcare rationing 2020-05-12
- WELSH GOVERNMENT PROVIDES ADDITIONAL £500 PAYMENT FOR SOCIAL CARE WORKFORCE 2020-05-01
- WELSH STEPS TO EASE COVID-19 PUBLIC HEALTH MEASURES – UPDATE 2020-04-24
- THREE WEEKS FOR REFLECTION – COVID 19 WALES 2020-04-18
- A HEALTHIER WALES — GOOD PROGRESS BUT GREATER URGENCY NEEDED 2020-01-06
- REMEMBERING DR JULIAN TUDOR HART. 2019-07-04
- WELSH GOVERNMENT ANNOUNCES INCREASED GP TRAINING PLACES 2019-06-25
- WELSH GOVERNMENT INVESTMENT IN GENERAL PRACTICE 2019-06-25
- PUTTING THE BEVAN PRINCIPLE IN PLACE .. 2019-03-06
- JULIAN TUDOR HART — A TRIBUTE BY PROFESSOR GRAHAM WATT. 2019-02-12
- Caring for an ageing population – some Welsh perspectives 2019-01-27
- ‘LEGISLATION WATCH WALES’ – October 2018 2018-10-18
- A Healthier Wales? Cymru Iachach? 2018-08-30
- SOCIAL CARE PRIORITIES & OPTIONS IN WALES 2018-05-26
- Letter in response to news item on oral health 2018-05-17
- PLANNING IN THE WELSH NHS 2018-04-16
- HYPOTHECATION — MAGIC BULLET, PLACEBO OR SOMETHING WORSE? 2018-04-02
- Will Parliamentary Review Deliver Major Change in Wales? 2018-03-18
- WELSH HEALTH AND SOCIAL CARE – PARLIAMENTARY REVIEW INTERIM REPORT 2017-10-11
- Legislation Watch Wales 2017-06-28
- NHS in Wales escaped the cyber attack 2017-05-16
- First Ten Years of Free Prescriptions in Wales 2017-04-20
- PRIMARY CARE NETWORKS IN WALES 2017-03-12
- REVISED GENERAL PRACTICE CONTRACT IN WALES 2017-03-06
- PARLIAMENTARY REVIEW FOR HEALTH AND SOCIAL CARE IN WALES — WILL IT BE A RUSHED JOB? 2017-02-27
- ‘LEGISLATION WATCH WALES’ – February 2017 2017-02-19
- Deemed Consent for Organ Donation – one year on in Wales. 2016-12-01
- The Question of Structure 2016-09-17
- Wales in prudent health 2016-06-08
- What is on Offer for Health and Social Care in the Welsh Assembly Elections? 2016-04-26
- OECD & WELSH NHS — IMPROVING BUT NEEDS TO IMPROVE LIKE REST OF UK NHS 2016-03-29
- Legislation Watch Wales 2016-03-19
- NHS in Wales 2016-02-25
- SOCIAL CARE REVIEW IN SCOTLAND 2016-01-15
- SOCIAL WORK IN WALES VALUED 2016-01-14
- TACKLING INEQUALITY — CAN YOU FOLLOW THE MONEY? 2015-12-07
- Our health our health services 2015-10-20
- Congratulations 2015-10-18
- TTIP petition handed in to Geraint Davies MP 2015-10-10
- NHS funding: record-breaking cuts? 2015-10-06
- Legislation Watch Wales 2015-08-22
- Referred pain in the care system 2015-07-09
- Legislation Watch – Wales 2015-03-15
- Rural areas count the cost of broken political promises 2015-03-06
- NHS Wales 2015-02-15
- WHAT DO THE WELSH THINK OF THEIR NHS 2015-02-05
- Funding of Welsh NHS 2015-01-08
- Welsh Legislation Watch 2014-11-17
- Cancer Treatment Fund for Wales? 2014-11-06
- PRUDENT CHOICES FOR A PRUDENT WELSH NHS 2014-11-05
- Having a baby in Wales 2014-10-26
- Daily Mail claims on Welsh NHS 2014-10-24
- DAILY MAIL STILL GOOSE STEPPING ON THE TRUTH ABOUT WELSH NHS 2014-10-23
- Hilda Smith MBE 2013-04-13
- Bill to ensure safe nurse staffing levels in NHS Wales 2014-09-16
- Notes of SHA Cymru Wales Officers Meeting 2014-06-26
- Notes of SHA Cymru Wales Officers Meeting 2014-06-12
- Andrews Report — A failure of trust 2014-05-29
- Notes of SHA Cymru Wales Officers Meeting 2014-04-16
- Welsh NHS : Cameron and Hunt – Apologise to the House and to Wales 2014-04-15
- The Welsh NHS has much to teach the English 2014-04-12
- Welsh Public Health White Paper consultation 2014-04-04
- Legislation Watch – Wales 2014-03-06
- The NHS in Wales 2014-03-03
- Wales Cancer Patient Experience Survey 2014-01-31
- Williams Commission Report On Public Services in Wales 2014-01-26
- A New Kind of Doctor 10 A New Social Alliance 1988-10-23
- A New Kind of Doctor 9 The Necessity Of Community 1988-10-23
- A New Kind of Doctor 8 Accountability For And To Groups 1988-10-17
- A New Kind of Doctor 7 Accountability For and To Individuals 1988-10-16
- Strategic Capacity Planning in Wales 2014-01-16
- Minutes of the AGM, SHA Cymru Wales 2013 2013-12-16
- Notes of SHA Cymru Wales Officers 2013-09-29
- A New Kind of Doctor 6 A CRISIS OF ACCOUNTABILITY 1988-10-17
- A New Kind of Doctor 5 Measurement of Omission 1988-10-15
- A New Kind of Doctor 4 New Ideas in Old Structures 1988-10-14
- A New Kind of Doctor 1 Points of Departure 1988-10-09
- A New Kind of Doctor Foreword 1988-10-09
- News from Wales March 2013 2013-03-23
Welsh Government – Test-Trace-Protect
- Bevan Foundation
- Changes to the English NHS
- Clear Red Water Rhodhri Morgan 2002
- Free Prescriptions: A Welsh Solution To Welsh Health Problems 2007
- Health in Wales
- History is what you live: Health and regeneration in Wales
- Nye Bevan Lecture 2004
- Organising for Health: The Design of a New NHS for Wales
- Plaid Cymru health policy
- Targeting Poor Health in Wales -Townsend Report
- The Miner’s Canary, let it fly Inaugural Professorial Lecture given by Tony Beddow
- Welsh Policy Forum Consultation Document December 2004
- Welsh Policy Forum Consultation Document Health and Social Care October 2006
- Welsh Health and Social Care Committee
Minutes of the AGM, SHA Cymru Wales 2013
Contact Prof Tony Beddow ToneSue@aol.com